American Idol 10

I agree with J-Lo that James has been the most consistent of the top 13 singers and could win it. However it may have been different if Chris Medina was still around. Scotty and James did well on Carole King night so it could be a Scotty versus James final.

American Idol 10

This was one of the weaker weeks of the show - mostly due to song choice I think. Haley was the winner in that area (for best song choice that is) with her cover of " Rolling In The Deep" and it was a good performance too- possibly the best of that day.

Stefano went back home this week even though " Closer" was one of his best performances. Funny that Jimmy Iovine mentioned the word begging, as this week I was thinking that Stefano sometimes sang like he was begging for votes.

Scotty was probably the weakest this week but I guess his fan base managed to keep him out of the bottom three.

American Idol 10

This week was also quite good though not as good as the last one. I didn't think Paul was the worst one. The surprise performance was by Casey. " Nature Boy" is not a very catchy song but he sang it well. James was the other "risky" performer with " Heavy Metal" (not a very catchy song as well) but I thought he covered it well too. Scotty went back to singing country music and did a good job this week again.

Strange that Haley whom I wrote was the weakest one last week was the only one who was criticised this week but I dont think she was the worst one this week either. If I were to pick a bottom three - it would have been Jacob, Lauren and Stefano (the dark horse this year).

American Idol 10

This week was much better than the last one. I could not really pick a bottom three this week as almost all the performances were good. Possibly Haley was the weakest one. Best performances were by Casey and Scotty.

Here is the video of Casey singing "Have You Ever Seen The Rain?"

American Idol 10

Elton John Week was mostly a low key affair for the singers. Although Lauren Alaina did do a good cover of "Candle in the Wind", I still preferred the Elton John's version for Princess Diana.

Thia Megia went home this week even though she did a good cover of "Daniel". For this week, thought the bottom three should have been Casey, Stefano( the dark horse this year) and Naima.